On our recent trip digging for Herkimer Diamonds, I also picked up and kept chunks of calcite. I didn’t know what it was until someone told me. I am still learning all this stuff. But it looked interesting, and some of it was hard to tell from the diamonds (quartz) while it was dirty/muddy anyway. It was just easier to throw it in the bag.
But now that we are home, I have been cleaning up all the stuff we found. I am actually surprised at how many small chunks of calcite that we collected. Most are small, but a few pieces are larger with small pieces of rock attached.
I was reading stuff on the web and I found some stuff talking about the calcite. From what I understand, the calcite is one of the last things to form, and can form around the quartz crystals. So some of my small hunks of calcite might have Herkimer diamonds inside them. I know for sure a couple pieces do since the crystal is partially exposed.
But something else I learned was that the calcite can be disolved by soaking it in white vinegar.
So I took a few of the chunks of calcite with exposed quartz crystals, and set them in a bowl with distilled white vinegar. Right away, tiny bubbles started coming off the calcite. I kept checking back and I could see the quartz crystals becoming more and more exposed as the calcite was slowly eaten away. I placed some more pieces of calcite in the vinegar that may or may not have Herkimer diamonds in them. When I got up the this morning, the chunks were smaller. The bubbling action seemed to have stopped, so I replaced the used vinegar with some fresh vinegar.

and what happen?? Did the vinegar dissolver the calcite entirely???
Comment by Angie — September 23, 2008 @ 2:32 pm
It would have. But generally it disolved around the outside, and also where it attached to the quartz. So we were able to remove the quartz before the calcite was completely disolved.
Comment by Rob — September 24, 2008 @ 6:34 am
I too had Herkimer diamonds underneath calcite. I used muriatic acid to dissolve away the calcite. To my surpise, the muriatic acid reduced a lot of the dolomite rock to sand, exposing more diamonds. Some of the diamonds are attached to the hydrocarbon anthraxolite. This method frees the diamonds without having to pry them off the matrix thus reducing the chance of damaging them. It works great, but extreme caution must be used when handling muriatic acid.
Comment by Joel Russo — October 10, 2008 @ 7:46 pm
So did you actually found Herkimer diamonds?
Comment by Diamonds — February 19, 2009 @ 3:51 am
Lots of them!
Comment by Rob — February 19, 2009 @ 7:46 am
Muriatic Acid works super good at dissolving the surrounding rock from matrix pieces and can clean up some of the quartz from higher elevations where it was closer to the soil and subject to staining and streaks through inclusions etc. Just be careful what you put it in and around, as the fumes that are emitted are super nasty, probably toxic, and will nuke your grass if you leave it closer than a few feet to it. If it comes in plastic, leave it in plastic (the acid that is). you can only buy it at pool supply places now in rochester (I buy it at Leslies in Greece). Lowe’s and the Home Freakshow do not stock it anymore. By the way, if you use it to clean stones and it leaves a yellowish residue on your quartz, change the acid out and dilute with water 1:1 and let it sit out of the sun for a day or so, they’ll clear right up (freaked me right out the first time it happened). I had a whole box of them from crystal grove from a few years back (was digging the easy stuff near the soil that trip) that were all crusty and brown and it cleaned ‘em up nice enough to put on my desk @ work (one is hardball sized and is now nice to have all squeaky clean).
Comment by Jeremy — March 1, 2009 @ 11:25 pm
It seems indeed a good idea to use vineager or muriatic acid to solve the calcium, as any chemistry course will learn you, you can also add water if you want the process to go slower, good luck with finding diamonds
Comment by diamonds — July 17, 2009 @ 7:13 am
hello, I am a huge rockhounder, have been most of my life and I am not getting into more of the what is what and looking for certian types, I have some big chunks of white rock, which i then believed to be calcite, now I have to try the vineager!! I am excited! THANKS!!
Comment by Bella — October 30, 2009 @ 3:15 pm